The Garneau Block, Todd Babiak, Random House 2006
There is always the temptation when you get a free book to look at it in the most favourable light possible. Everyone likes getting free books, especially when it was one you were planning on reading anyway. It is also nice when you get that free book signed and the author is nice and funny. But when it comes down to it, you can't forgive everything just because of a free book.
Random House is one publisher that truly recognizes the importance of librarians and booksellers to helping spread the word of books. I always appreciate this because some other publishers forget that if a bookseller or librarian doesn't want a book to sell/be borrowed, they have the power to stop this. Mostly, this is a note to authors- don't go into a bookstore and look down on the person helping you, they determine whether you sell of not.
Anyway, enough of a rant, on to the review.
Todd Babiak is a journalist for the
Edmonton Journal, and his book was originally published as a series in that paper. Currently,
the Garneau Block is on the long list for the Giller Prize. The plot of the novel involves a single block in Edmonton's Old Scona community. The block has been wrought with tragedy as of late. One of the families father was killed by police after he held hostage his wife and daughter. This event has a huge impact on the rest of the block and sets off a string of events that lead to the nearby University of Alberta, buying the property to build the new Vetrinary Medicine building. Secrets are revealed, relationships are built and destroyed, as the block's residences come together to save their piece of Edmonton's landscape.
The Garneau Block is written as a giant cliche of Edmonton, something which I found detracted greatly from the book. Because the entire novel was built on cliche characters they all lacked depth and the plot was moderately predictable, even in its absurd twists.
Being from Edmonton (and lived there for 18 years), I think I found this more frustrating than those who have never been to Edmonton might. A friend of mine from work, who also got a free copy, has read the book and really enjoyed it. That is not to say the book didn't have some positive features. There was a humour about it that I enjoyed and the plot kept me reading to the end (I have been known to abandon books). But there was something missing, and I think this something was in the writing quality.
Despite it being free and about my beloved hometown, I have to give this book 2/5 stars
But, if you did like it, then try:
Number One Ladies Detective Agency- Alexander McCall Smith
The Way the Crow Flies- Ann Marie MacDonald
Watching Desperate Housewives